Types of Term Life

Annual Renewable Term (ART):

• Premiums start low and increase each year as the insured ages.

• Cost-effective for young, healthy adults, but can become expensive over time.

Level Term Insurance:

• Premiums are fixed for the length of the term (e.g., 10–30 years).

• Provides stability and predictability for budgeting.

• After the term ends, renewing coverage is more expensive, often higher than comparable permanent policies.

Benefits of Term Life Insurance

• Affordable initial premiums, making it ideal for young families or temporary needs.

• Covers income replacement if the insured passes away unexpectedly.

• Can serve as collateral for loans or mortgages.

• Convertible term policies help preserve insurability for future permanent coverage.

Limitations of Term Life:

• Does not accumulate cash value.

• Coverage is temporary; premiums may increase with age if renewed.

• Can become expensive over time if coverage is extended beyond the original term.

Who Should Consider Term Life Insurance?

Term life insurance is best for those who:

• Need affordable coverage for a specific period (e.g., until children are independent or a mortgage is paid).

• Want to protect income for their family or dependents.

• Plan to purchase permanent life insurance later when finances allow.

• Seek a cost-effective way to cover temporary liabilities like business loans or debts.

Buy Term and Invest the Difference: Does It Really Work?

When it comes to life insurance, one of the most debated strategies is “Buy Term and Invest the Difference” (BTID).
This approach has been championed by many financial advisors as a way to get affordable coverage while building wealth through disciplined investing.
But does it actually make sense for everyone? Let’s break it down.

What “Buy Term and Invest the Difference” Means

The strategy is simple in theory:
Instead of purchasing a permanent (whole life or universal life) policy that includes a savings component, you buy a term life policy — which typically costs much less — and invest the money you save on premiums.

For example, if a whole life policy costs $1,800 per year and a comparable term policy costs $250, the “difference” of $1,550 would be intentionally invested in other assets, such as mutual funds or index funds.
Over time, the idea is that the investments could grow enough to replace the need for life insurance altogether.
(Western & Southern Financial Group)

The Benefits

1. Lower Initial Cost
Term life insurance is significantly more affordable than permanent coverage. That allows individuals to protect their families now without straining their budget.
(NerdWallet)

2. Greater Investment Control
Instead of letting an insurer manage the cash value portion, BTID lets you decide where to invest — whether that’s in a retirement account, stocks, or mutual funds.
(Securian Financial)

3. Flexibility
For those who only need life insurance for a certain period (e.g., until the mortgage is paid off or children are grown), BTID can be an efficient approach.

The Risks and Misconceptions

While appealing in theory, “buy term and invest the difference” can fall short if not executed with discipline.

1. It Requires Commitment
Many people don’t actually invest the difference — they simply spend it. Without consistent investing, the strategy fails to deliver the intended financial security.
(Securian Financial)

2. Market Volatility
nvestment returns are not guaranteed. A 2021 study by Wade D. Pfau published in the Journal of Financial Planning found that while investment-based strategies can outperform whole life under certain conditions, they may expose individuals to significant market volatility—especially in retirement or near the end of a term policy.
(Pfau, W.D. “Investigating the Role of Whole Life Insurance in a Lifetime Financial Plan,” Journal of Financial Planning, 2021)

Also, according to Forbes Advisor (2023), the risk of timing a market downturn can make “buy term and invest the difference” far less effective for those nearing financial milestones or retirement.

3. Temporary Protection
Term life policies eventually expire. If you still need coverage later in life — when your health may have changed — renewing or converting can be costly or even impossible.
(National Association of Insurance Commissioners)

4. Oversimplification
Some analysts argue that BTID oversimplifies financial planning by ignoring benefits of permanent life insurance, such as guaranteed lifelong coverage, tax-deferred cash value growth, and estate planning advantages.
(InvestmentNews)

Choosing What’s Right for You

The right choice depends on your goals, discipline, and financial situation.
The NAIC recommends evaluating:

• How long you actually need coverage.

• Your dependents’ future financial needs.

• Whether you’re likely to invest the premium difference consistently.
  (NAIC Consumer Insight)

If you’re disciplined, have a long investment horizon, and are comfortable with market risk, BTID could be a sound wealth-building strategy.
But if you value lifetime protection, stable cash growth, and tax-advantaged access to funds, a permanent policy may serve you better.

Final Thoughts

“Buy Term and Invest the Difference” isn’t a one-size-fits-all formula.
It’s a philosophy built on the assumption that you’ll invest consistently and wisely — and that markets will cooperate over time.
For some, it’s a stepping stone toward financial independence; for others, it’s a risky shortcut that leaves gaps in coverage later in life.

As with any financial decision, the smartest approach is to educate yourself, run the numbers, and consult a licensed advisor who can design a plan aligned with your goals, time horizon, and legacy vision.

Recent Studies & Industry Insights

Recent financial research continues to evaluate the long-term results of “Buy Term and Invest the Difference.”

• Journal of Financial Planning (2021): Wade Pfau’s study highlights that BTID’s success depends heavily on consistent investing behavior and market stability.

• Forbes Advisor (2023): Notes that many individuals underestimate their emotional response to volatility, often missing out on compounding returns by withdrawing early.

• Morningstar (2020): Suggests that investors often fail to maintain disciplined reinvestment, eroding the expected advantage of BTID.

• InsuranceNewsNet (2022): Reports that rising term costs in later years can make permanent policies more cost-effective for long-term legacy planning.

These findings reinforce that while BTID can be a smart strategy for disciplined investors, it’s not a universal solution.

Sources

1. Western & Southern Financial Group – What Does It Mean to Buy Term and Invest the Difference?

2. NerdWallet – Term vs. Whole Life Insurance: Differences & Which Is Best

3. Securian Financial – Buy Term and Invest the Difference (PDF)

4. Financialplanningassociation.org - Investing the Role of Whole Life Insurance in a Lifetime

5. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) – Life Insurance Basics

6. InvestmentNews – Study Says Buy Term and Invest the Difference Is “Bunk”

   Additional References (2019–2024)

   • Wade D. Pfau, Journal of Financial Planning (2019/2021) – Investigating the Role of Whole Life Insurance in a Lifetime Financial Plan

   • Forbes Advisor (2023) – Buy Term and Invest the Difference: Does It Really Work in Today’s Market?

   • Morningstar (2020) – Why Investors Fail to Capture Market Returns

   • InsuranceNewsNet (2022) – New Research Challenges the Long-Term Efficiency of BTID Strategies

Go back